Tuesday, February 02, 2010

Despite trades, Flames and Leafs still in the wilderness

Call it the Unofficial Start of Deadline Day. On Sunday, Toronto Maple Leafs GM Brian Burke swung two trades that saw his team acquire defenceman Dion Phaneuf from the Calgary Flames and goaltender Jean-Sebastien Giguere from the Anaheim Ducks, all for secondary roster players. Then, on Monday night, after being invisible (like much of his now former teammates) in the Flames’ 3-0 loss to the equally listless Philadelphia Flyers, Olli Jokinen was shipped out of Calgary to Madison Square Garden in exchange for “project” players Christopher Higgins and Ales Kotalik. With some big names traded already, it may just be a matter of time before others (Sheldon Souray, Teemu Selanne and, biggest of all, Ilya Kovalchuk) get their tickets to new towns as well.

The trades break down as follows:

To Toronto: D Dion Phaneuf, LW Fredrik Sjostrom, D Keith Aulie

To Calgary: C Matt Stajan, LW Niklas Hagman, RW Jamal Mayers, D Ian White

To Toronto: G Jean-Sebastien Giguere

To Anaheim: G Vesa Toskala, LW Jason Blake

To Calgary: RW Ales Kotalik, LW Christopher Higgins

To NY Rangers: C Olli Jokinen, LW Brandon Prust

In the short term, the deals allow each team to address needs and move players they had no need for. Phaneuf wore out his welcome in Calgary and now gets transferred to the Leafs, who desperately needed Phaneuf’s physical game with Mike Komisarek out of the lineup, while the Flames acquire much-needed forward depth. Giguere’s $6 million contract was too much for the Ducks to pay for a player relegated to the backup role, so he’ll get a chance to prove he’s still a starter in Toronto. Meanwhile, Anaheim gets a proven backup in Toskala and needed secondary offence in Blake, two players signed by former Leafs GM John Ferguson Jr. as cornerstones that didn’t pan out and fit better at reduced roles. Finally, Jokinen, Kotalik and Higgins- all players with past success on older teams- get a chance to revive their careers in different locales, their new teams hoping they can reclaim their former glory.

In the long term, it signals that the rebuilding projects in Calgary and Toronto are definitely on. The Leafs were already assumed to be on their project when the season began, as Burke has traded or reassigned all but seven of the Leafs’ roster from opening night 2008-09 and will likely pull off more trades with the offence the way it is. The Flames’ situation was brought on by the fact Calgary has been a large disappointment this season, fighting for their playoff lives when prognosticators were convinced the Flames would contend for the Conference title, so in trading Phaneuf and Jokinen it’s thought the Flames are revamping their roster to prepare themselves for a summer push. In either case, both are examples of abject failures of management to build the team they thought they were getting, and both deals leave more question marks than answers.

In Toronto, the deals mean that the Leafs are bolstering their defence at the expense of their forward corps, who look incredibly bare after Phil Kessel. It was assumed that the defence was set entering the season and that any moves that would be made would be for forwards, so the Leafs’ acquisition of Phaneuf- no matter how gifted he may turn out to be- is a head-scratcher. Not only that, but Phaneuf is yet another big, immobile body who really doesn’t fit with the Leafs’ defence corps as it’s constituted. For Phaneuf’s game to be completely effective, Phaneuf- like all big defencemen- need to be paired with a mobile defenceman (Scott Stevens, most often compared with Phaneuf, was paired with Brian Rafalski, who was mobile). The Leafs only have Tomas Kaberle in that regard, leaving holes in the other pairings. Perhaps Sjostrom, a commendable penalty killer in Calgary, will get used here as a “third” defenceman, playing deeper in the slot so that he can be mobile in the defensive zone and facilitate breakouts, but that will leave Toronto thin up front. I’ve always trusted that Burke knew what he was doing, because he was responsible for bringing the Vancouver Canucks into relevancy and he didn’t achieve that job in a single season, but unless more trades are coming, this deal leaves a lot to be desired. The Giguere deal is solid, because it allows the Leafs to have a proven starter to give Jonas Gustavsson some time to work in some consistency in his game, though I’m not sure why Giguere would want to go to Toronto where he’ll likely not be in the playoffs for the remainder of his contract, even if Francois Allaire is a coach in Toronto.

In Calgary, the questions are deeper and more important- pundits already knew the Leafs would be rebuilding, but the Flames were not supposed to be in that mode. At the forefront are the departures of Phaneuf and Jokinen, two players pegged to be cornerstones of the Flames traded at values that are not indicative of that stature. Stajan, Hagman and White (all from the Phaneuf deal) do add needed elements to the Calgary lineup, namely secondary scoring (from Stajan and Hagman) and mobility from the point (White), but none compare with Phaneuf, either on their own or together. Kotalik and Higgins are in the same boat- they’re both solid players, but together they don’t bring to the table the talents that Jokinen brought. Still, neither Phaneuf or Jokinen were panning out the way it was thought they could- Phaneuf not rounding into Norris Trophy form and Jokinen struggling to discover his form with the Florida Panthers, where he was “Mr. Everything”- with questions hanging over their work ethic that suggested both were too smug in Calgary to stay; but there’s no doubt that GM Darryl Sutter could have received more for both players. Further to this point is the fact that Sutter acquired both players, Phaneuf at the 2003 Draft and Jokinen at the deadline last year, so he’ll have to answer as to why two of his “core” selections didn’t develop like they were supposed to, especially if they do work themselves out. There’s speculation that with all the expiring contracts that Calgary acquired will mean the Flames will take a run at Kovalchuk in the summer, but that’s a big gamble to take; and even if it works, it still leaves Calgary bare at forward. The Flames seem to be operating at “stop-gap” mode, choosing to fill their holes with bubble gum instead of waiting to find the nuts and bolts that actually work, and it’s having a deleterious effect on the team. Kind of like their fellow 2004 Conference Finalists in San Jose, the Flames have been seduced by their one magical year and thought the solution was to get better on paper. Unfortunately, games are played on the ice, and the game that’s played on the ice takes a lot longer to build than it does on paper.

Going forward, it’s plain that more work needs to be done- Toronto needs to find some forwards for its system to work and Calgary has to figure out what system it’s going to run in the long run. Big names may have been swapped but questions still abound about how the newcomers will eventually fit where they are, and neither market seems patient enough to wait. January 31, 2010 and February 1, 2010 will be dates that will mark the legacies of Brian Burke and Darryl Sutter- it’s now up to them to see to it that they are positive ones.



Post a Comment

On comments:

Under no circumstances will flaming, trolling or any other kind of derogatory or malicious remark be tolerated, to myself or other posters. I expect all discussions to be civil and respectful, and any comment which does not adhere to that will be deleted. Disagreements- with myself or other posters- are fine, as long as you are respectful and provide a reason for your disagreement.

Furthermore, advertisements are not permitted within a comment. Any advertisement found in a comment will be deleted and reported as spam. Do not also ask me in a comment if you can advertise as I will also treat this as spam.

Finally, please comment under a name (the option exists above "Anonymous"). Anonymous posts will not be accepted.

Thank you.


Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Subscribe to Posts [Atom]